Live corpus
What we scanned
Every figure below is read from the pipeline for the dishes we have scored so far. Updated when the site is rebuilt. Totals: 5,371 rated recipes and 225,601 ratings across 9 dishes.
Dishes
| Dish | Current #1 |
Rated | Sites | Ratings |
Conf. | P(#2>#1) | Status |
| Pot Roast |
Stracotto (Pot Roast) with Porcini Mushrooms foodnetwork.com |
1,049 |
51 |
51,975 |
93% |
6.1% |
FROZEN_WITH_DISCLOSURE
2026-07-27 |
| Traditional American Fried Chicken |
Buttermilk Fried Chicken foodnetwork.com |
663 |
39 |
28,784 |
90% |
10.5% |
REOPENED
2026-07-28 |
| Bacon, Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich |
NYC Bagel and Egg Sandwich foodnetwork.com |
83 |
22 |
742 |
64% |
48.8% |
SCORED
— |
| Marry Me Chicken |
Marry Me Chicken littlesunnykitchen.com |
27 |
23 |
4,929 |
89% |
1.1% |
FROZEN_WITH_DISCLOSURE
2026-08-02 |
| Smoked Picanha |
The Best Method For Smoked Picanha smokedbbqsource.com |
13 |
13 |
82 |
53% |
39.6% |
SCORED
— |
| Lasagna |
Easy Skillet Spicy Butternut Squash Lasagna halfbakedharvest.com |
1,620 |
48 |
46,893 |
82% |
30.7% |
SCORED
— |
| Chocolate Chip Cookies |
Brown Butter Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies halfbakedharvest.com |
1,080 |
46 |
42,975 |
84% |
43.0% |
SCORED
— |
| Pizza Margherita |
Bobby Flay's Margherita Pizza foodnetwork.com |
47 |
18 |
606 |
61% |
40.8% |
SCORED
— |
| Banana Bread |
Sour Cream Banana Bread food.com |
789 |
45 |
48,615 |
92% |
20.0% |
SCORED
— |
P(#2>#1) is the measured probability that the runner-up is actually better given current evidence. High values mean a tight race, not a broken ranking.
Known gaps by dish
From freeze records where present. Gaps are named rather than hidden.
Pot Roast
- Allrecipes — Sampled at top 5 by vote count (see highVoteDig). 35 lower-vote candidates discovered but not verified -- per vote-mass analysis, none can independently reach the top 20.
- Serious Eats, Simply Recipes, The Kitchn, and the rest of the Dotdash Meredith network — Blocked (403). Not sampled. Lower priority than Allrecipes was, since none is known to carry comparable vote volume for this dish; not verified false.
- America's Test Kitchen, Taste of Home — UNVERIFIED -- real advertised ratings present, zero recoverable review data. ATK confirmed via 25-recipe sample. Taste of Home's reviews are gated behind an authenticated Viafoura API (confirmed reachable: 401/405/400 responses, not 404) -- not pursued per dig-gate question 6 (maintenance sustainability), ~48 recipes not worth an auth-token dependency. As of pipeline v2.1 (2026-07-29): EXCLUDED from CrowdScore ranking entirely (was previously ranked at full 'reported' weight despite this file already documenting it as UNVERIFIED -- that was a real enforcement gap, now fixed in analyze.mjs / sites.mjs UNVERIFIED_SITES).
- Bon Appétit, Epicurious, NYT Cooking — NO_PUBLIC_RATING -- no star system in markup at all. Qualitative citation only, out of scope for CrowdScore by design.
- Cookbooks, restaurant recipes, non-English sources, video/social — Structurally excluded from GüdScore v1 per policy. Named, not silently omitted.
Traditional American Fried Chicken
- Allrecipes — Sampled top 5 by vote count among in-scope titles. Does not enter top 10. CF blocked full JSON-LD; ratings from public index of live pages.
- Serious Eats / rest of Dotdash — Blocked. Not sampled. Lower priority after Allrecipes dig closed ranking risk.
- ATK / Taste of Home — In corpus; UNVERIFIED posture for review recovery (same as pot roast).
- food.com — QUARANTINE + RECOVERED.
Bacon, Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich
No freeze-record gap list on file yet.
Marry Me Chicken
- Allrecipes — Zero URLs from the automated sitemap harvest (same block as pot roast). A classic Marry Me Chicken entry (4.8/155 votes) was separately dug and merged; not a bounded high-vote sample the way pot roast's Allrecipes dig was, just the one verified entry.
- Serious Eats, Simply Recipes, food52.com, dinnerthendessert.com — Blocked (403/429) or zero URLs from the automated harvest. Not sampled. No known reason to expect comparable vote volume to littlesunnykitchen.com or tamingtwins.com, but not verified false either.
- America's Test Kitchen, Taste of Home — UNVERIFIED -- real advertised ratings, zero recoverable review data. Excluded from CrowdScore ranking entirely (2 recipes).
- Cookbooks, restaurant recipes, non-English sources, video/social — Structurally excluded from GüdScore v1 per policy. Named, not silently omitted.
Smoked Picanha
No freeze-record gap list on file yet.
Lasagna
No freeze-record gap list on file yet.
Chocolate Chip Cookies
No freeze-record gap list on file yet.
Pizza Margherita
No freeze-record gap list on file yet.
Banana Bread
No freeze-record gap list on file yet.
Machine-readable
JSON snapshots for tools and AI systems: